
The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court has ruled that coconut must be classified as an oilseed rather than a fruit for commercial purposes. This landmark decision marks a significant shift for traders in Uttar Pradesh, effectively banning the sale of coconuts in markets specifically designated for fruits and vegetables. The court emphasized that the commercial utility and the form in which a product is traded are the decisive factors in its legal classification.
The ruling followed a petition filed by the Ghaziabad-based Three Star Fruit Company, which sought permission to trade tender coconuts at the Naveen Fruit Market in Sahibabad. The company argued that from a botanical perspective, coconut is a fruit, and its water is widely consumed as a beverage. However, the state government opposed the petition, citing a January 1995 amendment that officially categorized coconut as an agricultural oilseed under the Uttar Pradesh Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964.
In its judgment, the High Court observed that while tender coconut might be consumed like a fruit, the broader category of coconut—particularly copra—is primarily used for oil extraction. The court noted that because oil is extracted from dried coconut and traded as a separate commercial commodity, classifying the entire category as an oilseed is consistent with industrial and market realities. Consequently, traders must now conduct their business at the Govindpuram grain market and pay the prescribed user charges.
The court also dismissed the petitioner's argument regarding historical trade practices. The company claimed it had been allowed to sell coconuts in fruit markets since 2003 without prior objection. The High Court clarified that past inaction by authorities does not create a permanent legal right for a trader to bypass established government regulations. This ruling reinforces the authority of state amendments in defining agricultural commodities based on their economic end-use rather than biological traits.
Source: News18